Wyoming Health Care Commission

 

Keyword:

Commissioners | Links | Meeting Minutes | Reports | Archives | Statutory Mandates | Calendar | Legislative Tracking | Home

Wyoming Healthcare Commission
May 8, 2006
Casper, Wyoming

Access & Affordability Committee

Medicaid Committee

Rural Health Care Delivery Systems Committee

May 8, 2006

ATTENDANCE:

Dixie Roberts, Chairman; Rex O. Arney, Rod Barton, Barbara Cohee, Jack Glode, M.D., Carol Jenkins, Steve Mossbrook, Barb Rea, Lorraine Saulino-Klein, John Vandel, Commissioners; Ken Vines, state Insurance Commissioner, Brent Sherard, M.D., Department of Health Director, Ex-Officio Commissioners; Lee Clabots, Deputy Director of Administration Wyoming Department of Health; John P. McBride, Lynn Birleffi, Rick Schum, Beth Wasson, Linda O'Grady, Darryl D. Bindschadler, M.D., Greg Gruman, PhD, Teri Green, Mary Burman, Jerry Calkins, M.D., Dan Perdue, Susie Pouliot, Committee Members; Susan Anderson, Executive Director, Beth Worthen, Assistant Director, Susie Scott-Mullen and Keith Hageman, Administrative Assistant, WHCC staff.

GUESTS:

Senator Charles K. Scott; Representative Pete Jorgensen; Julia Robinson, MPA, DPA; Christian Jones, AHIP; Lynne Weidel, Office of Rural Health; Tom Gallagher, Department of Employment, Research & Planning; Dan Lex, APS Healthcare and Quality Health Care Foundation; Bev Morrow, Wyoming Department of Health- Aging Division; Mary Behrens, Wyoming Nurses Association; Carole Shotwell, Board of Medicine; Pennie Hunt, Wyoming Health Resources Network; Lora Huston, WLRA & AHIP; Marian Schulz, Pfizer; Dick Torkelson, M.D.; Lynne Whalen, Natrona County Medical Society; Marcia Shanor, Wyoming Trial Lawyers Association; Barb Waters and Sharon Montagnino, Wyoming Nurses Association.

9:00 am Meeting called to order by Chairman Roberts

I. Introductions 

II. Director's Report

•  Personnel

•  Susie Scott-Mullen has been contracted as a facilitator for the Insuring the Uninsured Committee.

•  Beth Worthen will now be the WHCC staff facilitating the Rural Health Care Delivery Systems Committee.

•  Susan Anderson will be facilitating the Medicaid Committee.

•  Deadlines for RFPS and Contracts

•  Legislative Deadlines- The Legislature wants our recommendations on the topics the WHCC is studying by November.

•  The WHCC needs to encumber necessary funds by June 30 th for the fiscal year 05.

•  Specialty Hospital RFP

•  The deadlines included in the RFP are: Aug. 1, 2006 , preliminary discussion of findings; Sept. 1, 2006 , Draft report to WHCC due; Oct. 1, 2006 , final report to WHCC due.

•  Rural Health Care Delivery Systems Committee RFP

•  Committee Chair, Jack Glode has been in contact with various experts who are expected to respond to the RFP.

•  The RFP is asking for an assessment of the optimal rural health care delivery systems and an assessment of the impact of healthcare services in Wyoming including the financial impact of Wyoming citizens going across the borders for care.

•  Health Professions Tracking Study (HPTC)

•  Kolene Kohll from the University of Nebraska , Health Professions Tracking Center (HPTC) presented preliminary findings to Chairman Dixie Roberts, Dr. Jack Glode, Dr. Brent Sherard and Susan Anderson on April 13 th in Cheyenne .

•  The study, to date, reveals that about half of the doctors licensed in Wyoming do not practice in Wyoming and that 46% of dentists practicing in Wyoming are between 51-65 years of age and 43% of actively practicing physicians are in that same 51-65 years old range.

•  Nursing Study

•  Executive Director Susan Anderson will be working with Tom Gallagher, Department of Employment, Research and Planning (R&P), on Tuesday, May 9, 2006 , to draft the contract for the study.

III. Uninsured State Initiatives, Christian Jones, AHIP

Christian Jones from America 's Health Insurance Plans (AHIP) gave a presentation on "Uninsured State Initiatives." He looked at the following:

•  What's Our Problem?

•  Cost

•  Demographics

•  Technology Gap

•  Different State Approaches

•  Massachusetts Individual Mandate

•  TennCare / Cover Tennessee

•  Dirigo in Maine

•  Fair Share Legislation

•  Healthy New York Programs (WyoCare)

•  AHIP's Principles on Providing Access to the Uninsured

•  Who are the uninsured?

•  Evidence Based Medicine

•  Transparency

•  Health Savings Accounts

•  Resources

•  www.ahipresearch.org

•  www.ahip.org

•  www.healthdecisions.org

IV. Universal Healthcare Research and Options, Dr. Dick Torkelson

Dr. Dick Torkelson from Cheyenne , Wyoming , gave his insight on "Universal Healthcare." He said, even using conservative numbers, the number of people uninsured in Wyoming is still far too high. He stated that the lack of health insurance is associated with a 25% higher risk of death. Obviously, health insurance does make a difference. He said change is necessary and if the goal is universal healthcare coverage there are two approaches that can be taken, one being "incremental" reform and the other being "comprehensive" reform.

•  INCREMENTAL APPROACH- Based on the continuation of employer provided coverage supplemented by expansion of public plans, i.e., Medicaid and Medicare. Including the following:

•  Increase tax deductions for businesses who offer insurance plans to their employees.

•  Provide incentives to employees to participate in the insurance plans

•  Tax credits for low income individuals

•  Mandates for companies above a certain size to provide basic healthcare coverage.

•  Decrease Medicare's age eligibility requirements.

•  Increase Medicaid's income eligibility requirements.

•  Implement Health Saving Account (HSA) plans.

•  Change deductibility requirements

•  Implement health insurance regulatory reform (creating a federal market for health insurance).

However, according to Dr. Torkelson the incremental approaches ultimately do not achieve universal health coverage.

•  COMPREHENSIVE APPROACH- There are three aspects to the comprehensive approach. They are as follows:

•  Mandates for insurance coverage coupled with subsidies to those who cannot afford health insurance.

•  Single payer system.

•  Healthcare Vouchers

According to Dr. Torkelson the best approach is "Healthcare Vouchers" as suggested by Dr. Victor Fuchs and Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel. Their program features ten (10) fundamental features:

  1. Universality- every American under the age of 65 would receive a voucher that guarantees and pays for services from a qualified insurance carrier.
  2. Choice- individuals would choose which basic health insurance plan suites their needs.
  3. Freedom- individuals would have the freedom to purchase additional services.
  4. Funding- would come from an earmarked value added tax.
  5. Not Governmental healthcare- does not require legislative changes.
  6. Employer based insurance would end.
  7. Medicaid and other means tested programs would be eliminated.
  8. Medicare would be phased out over time.
  9. Administration would be federal (health board) and regionally arranged.

•  Ability to have independent outcome measurement and analysis.

Dr. Torkelson said the voucher plan encourages healthy competition and allows for better allocation of resources. Also the coverage could remain constant (mobility from state to state). Dr. Torkelson believes the Healthcare Voucher plan has real merit and potential to work.

Sen. Charles K. Scott addressed the concept of a universal healthcare plan. Sen. Scott explained that we need to work on the exploding cost of healthcare first and then maybe look at a universal coverage plan. He said specifically the voucher plan would cause an increase in tax levels (in order to pay for the vouchers) that could not be sustained and would lead to bankruptcy for the country because there are no controls on the cost with the voucher plan. Sen. Scott said that the U.S. is spending 15% or more of our GNP on healthcare. While other developed countries are only spending 10% or less. There needs to be cost controls and we need to look at the structure and incentives that are driving the increasing cost of healthcare in the U.S. 

V. WHCC Issues

Chairman Roberts brought up several issue concerning the WHCC. They were as follows:

•  The WHCC received two responses for the Specialty Hospitals Study RFP (one from CBIZ and one from Center for Studying Health System Change) . Commissioners received a copy of the two responses at the meeting.

•  The WHCC needs to be looking at ways to help the WyHIO with funding. WHCC is open for ideas to help WyHIO.

•  At next month's WHCC meeting (June) APS will be doing "total health management" and then the following month they'll be able to give us their return on investment (ROI).

•  The next legislative session is a general session. WHCC recommendations need to be submitted to the Joint Labor, Health & Social Services Committee by October/November time frame.

•  WHCC has certain funds in the budget until June. Now is the time to use the money for additional expertise.

VI. Committee Staffing/Facilitators

Chairman Roberts announced that the three (3) WHCC Committees will be staffed as follows:

Susie Mullen- Insuring the Uninsured Committee

Susan Anderson- Medicaid Committee

Beth Worthen- Rural Health Care Delivery Systems Committee 

12:00pm - 12:30pm LUNCH

VII. Committee Work

The Insuring the Uninsured Committee, Medicaid Committee and Rural Health Care Delivery Systems Committee all had separate committee meetings. All three committees met as long as was needed to accomplish their goals for the day. Committee meeting minutes will be delivered to the WHCC as soon as they are completed.

4:00pm Meeting Adjourned

The last of the committees adjourned their committee meeting at 4:00p.m.

Top of page