Wyoming Health Care Commission

 

 

Keyword:

 

 

 Home | Members | Links | Reports | Statutory Mandates | Text Only Version

Wyoming Healthcare Commission
October 25, 2004 , Meeting Minutes
Casper , Wyoming

Attendance: Chairman T. Chris Muirhead, Commissioners George Bryce, Marlene Ethier, Jack Glode, M.D., Carol Jenkins, Paul Lang, Steve Mossbrook, Dixie Roberts, Jack Speight, John Vandel, Ex-Officio Commissioners Kenneth Vines, State Insurance Commissioner, and Deborah Fleming, Ph.D., Wyoming Department of Health Director, and staff Emily Genoff, Assistance Director, and project coordinators Jan Kruse and Kathy Krubeck.

Meeting called to order, 8 a.m.

Chairman Muirhead made introductions. The Commission has a new member, Marlene Ethier, MS, RN, Director of Nursing at Western Wyoming Community College and president of Nurse Educators of Wyoming . Diane Harrop is in Arkansas attending to a family member.

Karen Ouzts, RN, Ph.D., UW School of Nursing Assistant Professor, reported to the Commission on a recently-awarded three-year grant received from the federal government intended to encourage more Wyoming nurses to work toward four-year degrees (RN to BSN). The grant also will provide nursing students with public health competencies. The University is collaborating on the grant with Western Wyoming Community College and Central Wyoming College .

Wyoming is projected to be short 1,500 nurses in 2020. Even if the state increased nursing school enrollment by 90 percent, there would be no guarantee that Wyoming 's nursing needs would be met. Expansion of bachelor's degree completion to sites outside of the University will promote students staying in their towns. Associate degree nurses tend to stay in their communities after graduation because their families are there and they've gone to school at home. Four-year-degree students have detached from home, are young and have gone off to the University for their educations and are apt to be employed away from the state after graduation. Only 8 percent to 10 percent of associate's degreed nursing graduates in Wyoming proceed with bachelor's degrees in nursing, a rate worse than the national average.

The grant will allow students to map out a curriculum to complete their associate's and bachelor's degrees in four years on site, instead of finishing an associate's degree and then going back to get a bachelor's degree. Many students need to complete prerequisite courses before even beginning an associate's degree. Being able to complete associate's and bachelor's degrees in four years is a faster track. Students often cannot go to school full time. Even though the University has had online four-year degree options for four years, there was little understanding that getting a degree electronically was a possibility.

Bio-terrorism responsiveness, leadership, and feeling a responsibility to one's community by knowing federal Healthy People 2010 goals and their local applications are part of the public health competencies that are being taught. The grant allows the state to maximize and combine its nursing education resources. Increasing the number of bachelor's degreed nurses will encourage a greater number of nurses to go on to get master's degrees and doctorate degrees and become educators, as well.

Commissioner Mossbrook launched a discussion about the roots of the nursing shortage. When new career avenues opened to women, nursing school enrollments fell. Enrollments are again rising, however. Community colleges have increased their enrollments by 30 percent. Nurses will tell you that there is a problem in the workplace. At a nursing summit in June, nurses focused on workplace issues when asked to define what needs the most scrutiny when researching avenues for promoting nursing as a profession. People who leave nursing for good have spent a few months in a hospital or long-term care facility. Public health nurses, on the other hand, stay on. That's because they are treated well, feel respected, and have a solid practice. The average nurse in Wyoming is 46 years old, nursing professors average 50 years of age, deans are 55 years old on average, and the rest of the state's population is similarly aging.

There is going to have to be a position at UW or within the Board of Nursing, or a separate, legislatively funded research center devoted to figuring out the extent of the nursing shortage problem and the best means of addressing it. Traveling nurses are compounding the problem; money expended by hospitals in Wyoming for traveling nurses totals millions of dollars. That money gives nurses incentive to leave regular positions to become travelers because they make more money, get to decide when they're going to work, choose what shifts they'll work, and are able to avoid mandatory overtime. The use of traveling nurses is going to break the system if we don't do something about that. Hospitals pay entry-level nurses $18 to $21 per hour and Wyoming is the worst paying state in the United States .

Medication and geriatric aides are not considered a solution to the nursing shortage in long-term care. Adding additional aides to the group being supervised by nurses already only adds to their burdens. There needs to be collaboration among hospital and other facility nurses with nursing organization leaders and the Department of Health to resolve the issues of long-term care nursing needs. Nurses receive hiring bonuses and other financial incentives to start working in hospitals but then find the workplace to be disempowering. Post-graduate mentoring is needed to prepare new students to deal with the workplace.

Magnet status awarded by the American Nurses Association is a process that shifts hospitals' cultures to involve nurses in decision-making, promote educational advancement and implement evidence-based medicine. Poudre Valley Hospital in Colorado is a Magnet hospital; they don't have turnover, their patients are happy, physicians and patients now ask whether a hospital has Magnet accreditation before seeking care.

Commissioner Vandel posed this question: Where are we going to put our money -- in education, in hospitals and long-term care? Pharmacists, with an additional year of education, make between $45 and $65 an hour. High school students need to be encouraged to consider medical education in Wyoming . Nursing faculties are not adequately educated. There are not enough clinical opportunities with good patient loads and supervision in the state.

The grant's ability to address the nursing shortage crisis was examined at the request of Commissioner Glode. The intent of the grant is to increase competencies at the local level in evidence-based care. At the state level, collaboration on finding long-term solutions to nursing shortages will need to be driven independently from the grant. The Wyoming Commission on Nursing and Nursing Education has united all of the nursing organizations. Sen. Charlie Scott said the Labor, Health and Social Services Committee passed a bill in 2003 giving an incentive for expansion of nursing programs. For every eight additional nursing school slots, the Legislature agreed to pay for another faculty member. The University was not interested in participating. The University did not want the Legislature determining how many faculty would be employed in nursing. The community colleges were interested, however, so the expansion was at that level.

Sen. Scott said he agrees with supporting Magnet hospital accreditation or similar programs. His committee has been searching for a way outside of mandating that type of accreditation to get hospitals to pursue workplace culture changes. Because hospitals are open 24 hours, there is no way to get away from shift work but there are other things you can do to mitigate stress. Legislators would like to explore creation of new educational opportunities targeting long-term care. Sen. Scott said he is afraid if the Legislature doesn't create a medication or geriatric aide program or a limited LPN program, we're going to do without in our nursing homes and you can't have that. Ms. Ouzts said maybe we need to move toward a specialty care degree. We need to research what nursing home administrators and nurses think will resolve the problems in long-term care facilities, not attempt quick fixes without their buy in, she said. Rep. Jerry Iekel said that he is hearing from nurses that they are opposed to medical and geriatric aide certification.

Commissioner Glode said that hospitals have cut their budgets and nursing staffs to remain economically viable. But Magnet certification is costly and will force small hospitals out of business if it's mandated. He said he is not too sure the system can afford what we're envisioning here. It's going to take the kind of health care planning that we're supposed to be doing as a Commission now to solve your problem. Nursing relationships with their physicians are terrible. Nurses' training is inadequate, nurse-patient ratios are too high, patients are older and sicker, and medical-legal issues are increasing. Dan Perdue, Wyoming Hospital Association, said hospital administrators are aware there are problems with the stressful, chaotic environment of their facilities that drive their staffs to make speedy exits for lesser-paying, less demanding positions. Hospitals are concerned about workforce shortage issues outside of nursing. Some have looked at Magnet or Planetree certification to empower their employees. There are no silver bullets. Hospitals are participating in student employment fairs to attract new nursing students.

Reports from Subcommittee Chairs

Paul Lang – Healthcare Access and Affordability
Rural healthcare study Deliverable No. 2, key indicators and definitions, has been redrafted. We have the document and we're still going through the review process. Deliverable No. 3 is being corrected and refined to assure accuracy in the data. We're finding one of the best sources of information through this process is public health nurses. We feel Deliverable No. 3 is one of the most important pieces yet to come, since the data within it is going to be the basis for Deliverable No. 4, the rural healthcare model proposed for Wyoming . We have taken more time than we thought. The tentative date for Deliverable No. 4 is pushed back to Dec. 15. I'm more willing to let the date continue to slip so that we have good information instead of pushing to get it completed. I still believe we'll have the draft study by the end of the year.

The second item was getting into the WWAMI/WICHE programs. We held our first discussion last week. We're looking at the issues raised two months ago, including is there a way to develop an integration between the two programs so they complement each other -- at least in terms of medical education, is there a way these programs can be directed to address healthcare worker shortages in the state, should the program be expanded into dentistry, and how do we increase the enrollment in WWAMI without diluting the talent base. We're at the stage of meeting with the people who have an interest and varying opinions on this subject.

Commissioner Vandel said Rick Miller, a member of University of Wyoming President Phil Dubois 's Cabinet, put a proposed guideline together for the group to follow when attempting to resolve the issues of medical education in Wyoming and its cost. Commissioner Lang said the University has been open but there are strong opinions on these programs and how they can be improved. There has been a six- to eight-month timeline put forth, Commissioner Fleming said, for dealing with these issues that looks realistic. One of the interfaces that will need to happen is a conversation with the UW Trustees, she said. We have not talked about our relationship with the Trustees and how that could happen, Commissioners Lang and Vandel agreed. In terms of the WICHE, WWAMI and other medical education efforts at UW, that needs to happen.

George Bryce – Affordable Healthcare and Coverage
Because so many people are preoccupied with Constitutional Amendments C and D on the November Election Ballot and there so much misinformation being disseminated, I want to complement Sen. Scott for publishing in the Casper Star-Tribune that the Insurance Department does regulate malpractice insurance premiums. All the issues on affordability seem to be taking a backseat to the Amendment battle. If Amendments C and D pass, there will be a battle in the Legislature next year over how and whether to exercise the opportunity to cap non-economic damages and to create a medical review panel. But at that point, at least we'll have direction. At the national level, the subtle differences between the plans of President Bush and John Kerry will impact health insurance coverage and care locally. The message that isn't arising is the importance of personal responsibility. When there's 15 percent of Gross National Product (GNP) going into health and our Wyoming community is so small, there ought to be some way to make healthcare coverage affordable.

There are three meetings coming up that are going to be important. Kathy Krubeck and Linda O'Grady will be going to Washington , D.C. , in November for a State Planning Grant Program meeting. On Nov. 17 in Cheyenne , the Affordable Healthcare Coverage Subcommittee will meet with Navigant Consulting for a report on Medicaid waiver possibilities. The meeting will begin at 10 a.m. in the Qwest Building on the second floor. I hope we can come up with some sort of agreement with Medicaid to support low-income workers' healthcare coverage needs. At the subcommittee meeting today, we need some discussion about the budgeting of Wyoming 's State Planning Grant money.

Carol Jenkins – Healthcare Information Technology and Disease Prevention and Management (HANDOUT)
The healthcare IT study interviews were held and a decision has been made but must be approved by the Wyoming Department of Administration and Information. I expect an announcement by the end of the week. There were nine good, robust applications and there was a tie for third so there were four candidates interviewed. We're four weeks shy of the initial target. The bids came in within budget.

The disease prevention and management report has been submitted. The subcommittee's consensus was that we need to put money into prevention. One of the most exciting models we heard about was the McComb, Mississippi , model. Six communities are piloting this work in Wyoming . Founder Dr. Patrick Cooper said you treat every kid as if each one were your own. Dr. Cooper's model requires reconfiguring the way funding is spent for education and therefore it cost only $6,000 per year in Mississippi to implement his model. That's our recommendation – that we bring in more willing districts to the six-community pilot underway in Wyoming . Nineteen districts in Wyoming applied for Healthy Living Healthy Learning funding. We need to affect a generational change. We need to bring the communities in and have communities identify what their concerns and issues are. How do we achieve academic achievement? That's tied to health.

We also looked at the tobacco issue. The number one cause of preventable death in the state is the use of tobacco. One out of two people in the state smoke or use chewing tobacco. People who chew don't usually smoke. Our young people are using chewing tobacco at a much greater rate than other states. The Department of Health has spent several years building our tobacco use prevention community-based programs. Only one county doesn't have a community coordinator working to prevent tobacco use. We were told by an advocacy organization that a comprehensive approach to tobacco intervention is what is needed. Right now the Wyoming Department of Health is funding tobacco use prevention at 40 percent of the federal Centers for Disease Control's recommended level. Successful programs in California and Massachusetts are at 75 percent of the CDC minimums.

The third recommendation is to look at evidence-based treatment protocols. Some of this is starting to move forward in the Department of Health with regard to diabetes and cardiovascular health. We see evidence-based treatment protocols as an important step to bringing health to our residents. Colorado has a collaborative bringing together all the partners in healthcare to agree upon the appropriate guidelines for preventive care screenings and medical diagnoses. In Wyoming , more and more insurers are implementing disease management programs and the guidelines are the basis for starting that effort. If we have four or five different agencies and insurers implementing different guidelines, medical offices will not be able to comply. This might be a method for increasing immunization rates in the state. There needs to be a better method for getting protocol disseminated – current practices are not generating a large response.

The Division of Substance Abuse should become the Division of Addictive Diseases. We're seeing a common physiological pathway identified among things that we put in our bodies, illegal or legal, abused or just used. There is a common pathway identified by scientists studying genetics.

We're also looking at merging funding opportunities and efforts among different state agencies to tackle some of our problems, such as the obesity epidemic. How do we encourage recreation districts to get people to be more physically active, and what about using subdivision regulations as a means of promoting exercise? Merging funding of agencies working on parallel or Healthy Living Healthy Learning program. We have lots of opportunities to make this a synergistic effort.

Discussion followed regarding the state's smoking cessation intervention program efforts, and the Healthy Living Healthy Learning pilots. The pilots results are not going to be measurable for some time because they are following the very detailed Mariner model -- the first phase alone takes nine months. Commissioner Fleming said the Departments of Health, Family Services and Education are involved. The pilots mimic the McComb, Mississippi model closely. Commissioner Roberts said the more than $2 million price tag on adding more communities seems high when Dr. Patrick Cooper spent just $6,000 and much of what is required is educational in nature, and the results of Wyoming 's pilots are not in. Commissioner Fleming said that in McComb, they made a 13-year commitment. Their implementation was incremental. Commissioner Jenkins said in Wyoming , many schools have components of the model already in place. It's important to marry the educational components to the health of students.

Commissioner Mossbrook said that the Subcommittee examined creation of a separate state agency or office that would be responsible for comprehensive school health education and opted not to make that recommendation. The funding proposed by the subcommittee to expand Healthy Living Healthy Learning would go to the Department of Education, which is managing the six pilots. Commissioner Glode said school superintendents are not necessarily long-term champions; a full time position in each district is needed to master and run this type of program. The goal is to change the behavior of the community and what's popular and what's not popular. Sen. Scott said that we're having trouble with school districts achieving their basic mission – 20 percent of the kids are not learning how to read. I don't think legislative resistance will come over the dollars, it will be that we are putting too many responsibilities on the school districts. Commissioner Jenkins said the model would argue that until we deal with children's basic health needs (Maslow's hierarchy of needs -- food, clothing, shelter, security), they are not going to learn. We have not done a good job of teaching health literacy. Teachers have to overcome the problems of parenting. Sen. Scott said a public health program targeting infants was fully funded by the Legislature but due to the nursing shortage, the services are only reaching about half of those in need. One of the big components in that program is teaching parenting skills.

Commissioner Bryce said disease protocols can be linked to the IT work the subcommittee is doing, but he asked if there is any money to make progress toward creation of a disease management protocol “headquarters.” On his committee, the affordability of healthcare coverage and healthcare is a big deal, and protocols may reduce costs, so is there any money that can be allocated to help anything here? How do you implement this, Commissioner Jenkins said, is the question. My understanding of some of these projects is every partner brings in cash or in kind resources to develop the protocol. Commissioner Glode said there is skepticism about whether chronic disease management is going to save money. There are two goals – one is to make care cheaper and another is to make it better. The experts are trying to feel their way through these issues. It may be premature to have a short-term goal of implementing disease management guidelines from this level. There are some physicians and hospitals that are going to resist this because of cost .

 It was agreed that disease protocols and their uniform implementation will need to be discussed at the Commission's retreat later this year. Sen. Scott said he wants to appeal to the Commission that long term this may be one of the two or three most important things this Commission may take on. He said he knows personally that his fellow diabetics report vast differentiation in care, even though diabetes care protocols are among the first to be disseminated. Commissioner Jenkins said that costs might go up initially but the long-term effects of debilitating disease might be delayed or deferred. Commissioner Vandel said in Albany County , state employees are part of a pilot intended to reduce healthcare costs by $1 million through disease management. Commissioner Glode said that in order to treat chronic diseases, we're going to change the way we deliver care. The fee-for-service model isn't working. The private physician's office is not the place this is going to happen, it's going to happen in chronic disease programs that are comprehensive involving a cascade of treatment hierarchy on a long-term basis. It's much cheaper to do that, it's proven in heart failure (hospitalization rates are 50 percent less). But to get through the politics, the insurers, the professional organizations, takes time. Economic necessity will drive it. In the meantime, we need to encourage physicians to practice according to these guidelines. To change the way we deliver care especially in chronic disease management there are a lot of political hurdles.

Physicians and Surgeons Excess Liability Fund Study, Section 2 of HB 1010
The bill, passed during the Special Session of the Legislature in July, instructs the Wyoming Healthcare commission, with assistance from the Insurance Commissioner, to study issues relating to insurance reform and specifically 1) self-insurance pools or state-funded insurance programs to provide excess liability insurance for healthcare providers, 2) the Nebraska excess liability fund, 3) the practicality of a Nebraska-style excess liability fund for Wyoming healthcare providers, 4) similarities and differences between the Nebraska and Wyoming tort systems, as they would affect the practicality or advisability of a Nebraska style excess liability fund in Wyoming, and 5) estimated capitalization and other start-up expenses for an excess liability self insurance pool or state-funded insurance program.

Richard Lord of Milliman said the purpose of the Physicians and Surgeons Excess Liability Fund Study was to review suitable structures for a fund to cover the excess liability of the physicians of the state of Wyoming, to provide comparisons with other states -- specifically Nebraska and New Mexico, and to provide a pro forma analysis as to the impact of establishing a fund of that nature in Wyoming. To that end, Milliman reviewed the funds that were in place in various states, reviewed the tort systems in those states, provided a comparison, and developed several scenarios. The scenarios consider the information of those states and the Wyoming experience to anticipate the impact that would have on providing medical liability insurance in the state in Wyoming . One scenario is modeled after the Nebraska fund, which attaches at $500,000 indemnity paid per claim (there's an underlying insurance that pays up to $500,000). A couple additional scenarios are based on recent attachment points and limits in Nebraska – one with a $200,000 attachment point, absolute limit of $1.25 million, and one with an upper limit of $1.75 million. Another scenario is modeled after New Mexico with attachment at $200,000 and an upper limit of $600,000.

Finally, one scenario provides a more direct comparison with the current coverage in Wyoming primarily sold to physicians – a $1 million indemnity limit. In that situation, a physician would buy coverage from one of the providers in the state that would provide an indemnity limit of $500,000 per claim including all defense costs and the fund would provide coverage for claim amounts between $500,000 and an upper limit of $1 million. To fund that would, we estimate, require a 15 percent surcharge on the underlying policy premium and that's if no tort reform measures were enacted in the state. We also have run a second scenario with a $250,000 cap on non-economic damages and we calculate a 9 percent surcharge would be required. A cap on damages has a greater impact on the excess layers because those are the losses that are being capped out on the limit and a lesser impact on the primary layer because a greater percentage of those losses are being retained. The average cost per physician is calculated looking at the 2004 typical average rate and to get that we've taken the distribution of physicians by specialty type and taken a weighted average by specialty rates for 2004 and trended those forward by 5 percent to develop an expected 2005 rate. That average rate we've calculated to be about $34,780.

Starting with that average insurance cost assumption, we've then calculated what the expected cost of insurance would be if an excess liability fund were put into place and again the best direct comparison of how that might impact costs is to compare the base case with the Wyoming scenario. In this case we calculate the cost if the excess liability fund would be in place with an adequate surcharge and capital to assure the solvency of the fund would require $28,177 to buy a policy from a serving carrier at $500,000 limits plus $4,133 for the surcharge for a total cost of $34,120. The main Nebraska scenario is more expensive because the total coverage provided has an upper limit higher than typically purchased by Wyoming physicians today. One caveat is the administrative expenses for the fund (pegged at 2 percent for this study based on the Nebraska fund, which covers a larger volume of physicians and has a larger volume of losses). Another caveat is that these calculations assume the expenses for the underlying policy won't increase; we base those on the current rates the insurance providers have filed for $500,000 coverage. It's possible if their overall premium volume went down they might feel the need to revise and have a greater expense load as a percentage of premium.

Based on our pro forma financial statement calculations for the funds under various scenarios we've calculated at the level which we think would include a solvency margin, or an appropriate margin so that it's reasonably unlikely the fund would find itself in a deficit position. For that calculation we have determined the level of funding at a one-out-of-10-year-loss required so that in Year Two, a deficit assessment would not be required to keep the fund in a positive balance (Year One, $600,000). That amount is loaded into the surcharges. The fund would include near total participation by physicians in the state, it is assumed, whether or not it's mandatory. We have in fact calculated a set of surcharges we believe would be applicable if the fund were to become more of a residual market mechanism using rate adjustments insurance companies charge for physicians deemed to be undesirable risks. We've assumed that the fund will follow the form of the underlying coverage, which is “claims made” coverage with the same retroactive date (i.e. includes prior acts). Therefore, if the physician enters the fund with a mature, “claims made” underlying policy stretching back for a five-year retroactive date, the fund would then also cover reported claims with a retroactive date stretching back five years. If the physician entered the fund with a first-year covered policy, the fund would attach at the same first-year coverage.

We've assumed we're looking at a zero sum game – the funds will not change the underlying costs of medical malpractice liability coverage in the state. What it does possibly impact is delivering the cost of that coverage. When insurance companies are providing this coverage, they need to include a provision for a return on the capital that supports their risks. To the extent a portion of their risk is ceding to an excess liability fund that is a cost that does not need to be assessed. There will need to be some safety margin. The assumption is that over the long term, the fund will be managed toward a break-even point. Surpluses in previous years will eventually be returned to policyholders. Deficits in previous years will be assessed to make up the balance in later years. It's possible that there can be market problems resulting from an insufficient number of insurance providers and you can then have a situation where the cost of the coverage is excessive. It's possible with the exit of OHIC from the market that the market situation could deteriorate dramatically in the next year and then the numbers we're assuming for the base case rate could get worse over time. And if that's the case, the savings by the fund could be greater than those implied in the calculations included in this report. Excess liability funds can immunize the physicians from market fluctuations (changes in reinsurance costs, changes in the medical malpractice insurance market in Wyoming ). There are probably a large number of important considerations in addition to these in determining whether an excess liability fund is appropriate for the state.

Commissioner Mossbrook – You seem to be recommending the Nebraska scenario, which is in fact is a higher cost primarily because you're raising the coverage limit to $1.75 million. Can you shed any light on why? Chairman Muirhead asked what the Milliman recommendation is.

Mr. Lord said Milliman does not have a specific recommendation at this point in time other than stating our conclusions. I think that there are probably a large number of considerations that Wyoming needs to consider in the Legislature, and the Healthcare Commission need to consider, before going down this route. Off the top of my head I think that if tort reform or damages caps are enacted in the state, the need for an excess liability fund -- and particularly passage of a $250,000 non-economic damages cap -- diminishes greatly. I don't think it would make a lot of sense in that case, given that insurers adjust their rates accordingly (i.e. the savings implied by the cap are realized in the insurance rate). If nothing else is done in the state, if there's no tort reform or alternative insurer set up, then an excess liability fund based on Wyoming 's $1 million upper limit policy practice makes a whole lot of sense. If there is a fair amount of premium in that excess liability layer and the results were volatile to insurers, those types of things will increase the need for an excess liability fund in that it would tend to increase the affordability and availability of insurance in the state. Tort reform at the $250,000 cap level will reduce a lot of losses in that layer and consequently reduce the volume of premium needed for that layer, and reduce what would be unattractive to insurance companies which provide that coverage in the first place. The cost between having and not having an excess liability fund would narrow and for all those reasons, the benefit of having versus not having a fund would diminish.

The conclusions of the cap study provide the basis for the calculations in this report of the impact of the excess liability fund layer from enacting tort reform. We do in fact reference that report in this document. Discussion followed regarding the data in the first report and the viability of the OHIC numbers.

Commissioner Vines – A paragraph on Page 10 looks like a recommendation.

Mr. Lord -- I think the intent was to say that the primary focus of this analysis was Nebraska as a basis of comparison. That's not a recommendation I have.

 Commissioner Mossbrook – Given that the current scenario is a $1 million policy limit, can you hypothesize where a $200,000 to $1 million scenario would fit within this? All of your review areas are outside that with the exception of a scenario based on $500,000 to $1 million.

Mr. Lord – The closest to that scenario where we do $200,000 to $1.25 million, which provides a little bit more coverage going up to $1.25 million. The surcharge would go down by small amount total average cost something a little less than $31,500.

Commissioner Mossbrook said we need a broader range of tiers for this research to be applicable to Wyoming , not going above $1 million but going lower.

Commissioner Jenkins – Is there a disincentive not to do risk management if the attachment point is too low? How do you choose between attachment points?

Mr. Lord – The defense of a claim will lie with the insurance company. My initial reaction would be that be even at an attachment point at $200,000, the insurance company still has a lot of skin in the game and probably still has a large incentive to aggressively defend cases. It is true to some extent as the insurance company becomes less of a risk-bearing participant in the process, the economic incentive to aggressively defend is less. If the insurance companies are charging actuarially fair rates, the spectrum is tied to the affordability from complete lack of availability in the market. You get more bang for your buck in a $200,000 limit than a $500,000 limit.

Commissioner Mossbrook – Was sensitivity analysis done on the caps higher than $250,000?

Mr. Lord – No. Sensitivity analysis was no caps vs. $250,000 to bracket it. We didn't specifically quantify what those mid points would be because the cost savings is not all that great. A cap of $1 million would have a cost savings of 2 percent and would be close to a “no tort reform” scenario. As you get to $500,000, the other limit that we looked at our cost savings percentage went from 15 percent to 7 percent so that might be a reasonable midpoint. We can quantify it; we have all the information to do it.

Commissioner Mossbrook -- In your research, did you encounter instances where the fund had its own negotiator to protect its position in the settlements process?

Mr. Lord – I don't know if they actually participate in settlement negotiations. It's typically the case when you're dealing with an analogous situation, when you have a reinsurance company that provides a reinsurance treaty that writes a certain amount of business, it's possible the insurance company would have a disincentive to aggressively manage the costs that are in the reinsurance company's layer and the end result is their rates get raised.

Commissioner Mossbrook – So there is no way for us to inflict pain – the reinsurance company can, but we can't.

Commissioner Speight -- A doctor is sued with a $1 million policy and it's clear there was a medical error. That case can settlement for $100,000. What the insurance companies do is say okay, it's going to cost X dollars to have a full defense case. We'll put up $75,000 to settle and we want you (the doctor) to put up $25,000. The individual doctor has no hammer. If you don't participate, you go to trial and the doctor will be out of the office for three or four days. If we're going to make this recommendation, we can put a hammer in there legislatively that if we have an excess insurance pool that somebody comes to the table with some control over the insurance company, that they can't leave us out to dry like they do now with individual doctors. There needs to be some requirement that they have to negotiate in good faith with the same vigor as they do their own.

Commissioner Glode – Studying Nebraska, it seems to me they're getting into trouble with their costs. If you look at exhibit 16, I think you see the consequences of an excess liability fund without caps. The surcharge has followed the soft and hard markets. There is no insulation whatsoever. It looks like during the soft market of the 90s it got down to 5 percent and now it's up to 50 percent again. Is it true that Nebraska is worrying about their fund's cost?

Mr. Lord – yes their surcharge is up to 50 percent, the maximum allowable by law.

Discussion followed regarding the fund's recommended reserve. Commissioner Vines said that because this surplus fund is not going to accumulate capital, you need to be able to do deficit assessments. Mr. Lord said that the fund's surcharge should be based on the expected costs for the year that you're assessing for, adjusted by past surpluses or deficits. Essentially that's somewhat of a disincentive to doctors, Commissioner Vines said, because they know if you have a really bad year, they're going to have an additional or big assessment in the next year. I look at the percentages that you ran and they're not that great, $1,000 or $2,000. Doctors are always subject to an additional assessment, which might eat up that savings pretty quickly. Mr. Lord said while that sounds like an accurate assessment, he can't speak to behavior of doctors as they perceive that assessment. I work with a lot of programs such as trusts that have accessibility provisions and those don't seem to be a disincentive for doctors to participate -- generally because they are lower cost structures. It's possible that if a doctor could be assessed if rates are inadequate in the fund as opposed to an insurance company that is not allowed to go back and charge somebody because their rates are too low, that could factor into a doctor's buy in decision.

Commissioner Bryce – In states that have implemented excess liability funds, is there an improved medical malpractice insurance market?

Mr. Lord –I don't know the answer to that off hand but I think it's one that could be answered by looking at simply the number of carriers providing a reasonable amount of premium in the state in the years following the inception of the fund and that information is available from sources like AM Best. I think that's something I could look up. It's often the case that so many things come into play that it's hard to isolate one particular item as being the reason that insurers enter or leave a market but I think it would be possible in the case of some of these states simply to look at the market concentration in the years proceeding and following the establishment of a fund.

 Sen. Scott – A key to savings is the rate insurance companies charge for base coverage. I gather your figures came from looking at filed rates. Mr. Lord -- Correct. Sen. Scott -- Are those Wyoming rates? Mr. Lord -- Yes. Sen. Scott -- That's an unusual policy, is it not? Are there characteristics of the physicians that seek that kind of policy that would be significantly different that you couldn't rely on those rates? Mr. Lord – That's an unusual policy limit in Wyoming . Virtually all the policies sold are at $1 million limit. We spoke with the producers for OHIC and The Doctor's Co. that covered most of the policies written in the state and the indication we had from them was that there wasn't more than a few policies written at lower levels than $1 million. Whether that's rated, then, for an atypical insured, someone who might be either a particularly bad risk seeking to limit cost of coverage or good risk who didn't see the need to carry a lot of coverage, I would say that's possible. In my experience, the policy limits the pricing of those alternate policy levels is done on a formula basis where the insurance company takes their individual claim experience and some sort of a loss model and calculates the cost difference in their expected claims. I think because you're talking so few policies on the alternate limits, I've never seen those experience rated for some selection so I think it's possible but I don't think it's done that way. Sen. Scott -- I'm also unclear on the affect of medical underwriting in the policies. A lot of people are paying significantly more than the filed rate.

The Commissioners conducted a page-by-page review of the document, which will be revised by Milliman and resubmitted for a final analysis later this week. The report will be mailed to the Legislature on Monday, Nov. 1.

 Commissioner Speight – Was Milliman staff testimony in Texas taken into consideration, regarding the reliability of Texas , Florida and New York studies? I will talk with the Chairman give him a copy need to visit at your leisure this week.

Uncompensated Catastrophic and Trauma Care Study Report by Gwyn Davidson, Associate Director, Navigant Consulting

Chairman Muirhead reported there were difficulties with the data needed for the study and therefore the report was delayed by three weeks to allow for maximum participation by Wyoming hospitals.

Ms. Davidson said trauma and catastrophic care are critical to Wyomingites' well being, and access to those services are key to remaining productive and healthy. Wyoming has a trauma care system in which all hospitals participate. Any reduction in trauma care services would have a negative impact on communities.

There is overlap between trauma and catastrophic care definitions but they are not the same. Trauma care is defined by the Wyoming trauma care program, which incorporates a range of injuries to the body. Catastrophic care is care that can be defined using a diagnosis code or by cost. We tailored the definition by cost and to each hospital. The feedback given initially was that one case may be financially catastrophic for one hospital but not for another hospital. Therefore, the methodology adopted was calculation of the average cost of the hospital plus three standard deviations -- for inpatient care. It depends on the spread, the distribution of the hospital's cases. Our analysis showed we captured 2 percent to 3 percent of inpatient discharges, those truly high cost discharges. There are some people who have trauma care diagnoses who are also falling within the catastrophic care cost margin, but some trauma care recipients will not. Trauma cases are spread over age groups and usually involve an accident, typically a vehicular accident. Catastrophic cases had different diagnoses and were most often patients older than 60. Length of stay for catastrophic cases was much longer.

The definition of “costs” is critical to this study. Hospitals and other providers submit charges but we weren't looking at charges, we were looking at costs. We used Medicare cost allocation principles to allocate costs to determine how much a service might cost in different departments of the hospital. This approach is an industry standard but it is not always consistent with costs hospitals calculate in-house because Medicare doesn't include all costs as allowable. These estimates of costs are just that, they are estimates. But using Medicare principles allows for standard application to all hospitals.

A major basis for the report is the knowledge that hospitals are necessary to communities. Even though Wyoming Medical Center and United Medical Center provide the highest level of care, other smaller facilities are crucial for funneling patients into those facilities. There is a large amount of trauma and catastrophic care that is unreimbursed. What is difficult is to find one data source that tells us what the amount of unreimbursed care is as a whole, so we've taken different data sets to look at and quantify this. One of the first things we looked at was bad debt and charity care, which is not necessarily trauma- or catastrophic-care specific. It is care the hospital provides that it hasn't received payment for or has decided in advance to provide knowing there will be no collection. The uninsured have a lot to do with the amount of bad debt and charity care the hospital provides.

The Wyoming Hospital Association provided three years' worth of bad debt and charity care for the American Hospital Association's annual survey. Wyoming hospitals provided $66 million in charity care in 2003, representing a 26 percent increase since 2001, according to that data. We compared Wyoming 's bad debt and charity care provision rates to other states in the northwest region and Wyoming is higher than nationwide figures as well as the region. Wyoming 's rate is at 6 percent, compared with 5 percent nationally and 3 percent for the region. This would cause financial stress to Wyoming hospitals and particularly smaller hospitals with less ability to achieve economies of scale and spread the expense further. Estimated costs for services was obtained from Solucient, which uses a Medicare cost-to-charge ratio approach. This gives an estimated cost. Inpatient hospital 2003 costs for the uninsured totaled almost $16 million in costs. It's part of the $66 million in charity care.

Discussion followed regarding the approach used and how conservative its estimates may be. A hospital survey showed trauma care discharges totaled 10 percent to 12 percent of total charges and costs, and 9 percent of all inpatient discharges. We looked at the trauma care registry, Ms. Davidson said, which has been receiving data from hospitals for the last four to five years consistently. The registry provides charges. The estimated cost was about $10 million. Of that, $5.4 million was unreimbursed. We also saw the number of patients reported in the trauma care registry appeared to be about one-fourth in the trauma care dataset gathered from hospitals. Multiplying $5.4 million times four and you come up with $22 million in uncompensated trauma care. It is important over time to analyze whether these numbers are consistent.

Discussion followed regarding the uninsured and who they are. State Trauma Program Coordinator Maggie Cleveland said that many people are underinsured – they have some insurance coverage but it's insufficient to cover their expenses -- while others are without insurance. Sen. Scott said the Legislature has debated mandating a medical coverage limit but have opted not to because there are a number of people who find the price too high to pay as it is and therefore go get insurance and then immediately drop it once they've obtained licensure. Your means of policing that are Draconian and expensive, he said. If you raise what's required of drivers too high you get a worse problem than what we are already experiencing. High-risk behaviors are associated with the uninsured.

Navigant's hospital survey showed more about case-by-case inpatient and outpatient care scenarios. Twenty out of the 22 hospitals surveyed provided inpatient data, 16 provided outpatient data and 10 provided readmission data. We found that about $4 million out $30.17 million in catastrophic and trauma care was unreimbursed. Discussion followed regarding the shifting of unreimbursed trauma care costs to health insurance companies. Chairman Muirhead said that one of the Commission's legislative charges was to identify cost shifting and as a result of this report, we have identified true cost shifting in this area. Ms. Davidson said that not having any payments at all for care provided can cause financial stress for hospitals. With Medicaid and Medicare, you are getting some reimbursement.

Commissioner Glode expressed concern that the study was limited to the expenses borne by hospitals. “There's only a few physicians in the state who suffer the brunt of the load – the general surgeons, orthopedists, oral surgeons,” he said. “I think we need to make this part of our analysis. If something doesn't change, we're going to have a lot of difficulty recruiting general surgeons to the state to keep these programs running. It's becoming a problem in Cheyenne , Casper and Rock Springs . These patients get transferred immediately as soon as they are stabilized. Those are the surgeons who are having to take up the load. As you know, the follow up costs are also very expensive and the surgeons bear the brunt of that in rehabilitation.” Chairman Muirhead said that by legislative mandate, the Commission was only allowed to look at hospitals. Whatever you see here is probably mirrored in the physician component, he said.

Sen. Scott said that the other piece that is needed to make sense of the report is how much market share each payer has. You put the market share data in and you can see that your Medicare program is responsible for half the problem and bad debt and charity care is responsible for about a third -- but that's pretty crude. Ms. Davidson said that she prepared charts that look at that. Of $118 million in total charges over two years, $67 million is coming from Medicare, followed by private pay, and then Medicaid. You can do some math with this and see what percentage of cost shifting came from which source. Commissioner Vandel said he thinks this report shows the cost shifting into the private pay, which is paid primarily with insurance. The fact is that insurance companies are ratcheting down on what they are willing to pay. Mr. Mossbrook asked what percentage of trauma is shipped out; Maggie said less than 20 percent. Discussion followed regarding costs not incorporated into the study. Transportation is one of those costs. Ten air ambulances respond to Wyoming calls; the only hospital in Wyoming operating an air ambulance is Wyoming Medical Center . Trauma transportation system effectiveness needs to be studied. Twenty-five percent of ambulance agencies do not bill for services. It's better for them to not bill and instead have a contract with the county. There wasn't a database with trip specific charges. About 40 percent of all ambulance services are volunteer.

Options for consideration to funnel additional money to providers for unreimbursed care include replicating what other states have done by taking a capped pool of money and distributing that to physicians, hospitals and ambulance providers. The pool of funding could be based on unreimbursed trauma care costs, and/or unreimbursed catastrophic care costs. The level of funding determines the mechanism used to get that money. You would look at discharges that exceed a certain cost threshold and pay any unreimbursed cost over that threshold. You might be subsidizing other payers, like Medicare, by doing that. For those discharges that represent the uninsured, you are reimbursing a large portion of costs on a claim-by-claim basis. Another option we looked at is paying hospitals an amount equal to the hospital's uncompensated care. This is essentially taking the $66 million and paying hospitals back for a percentage of that. We examined giving hospitals back that percentage of their uncompensated care. We also looked at tweaking that according to a trauma care adjustment factor.

The third option, Ms. Davidson said, is to provide a catastrophic care pool for uninsured Wyoming residents. This targets the population that is clearly unreimbursed. We looked at if someone is uninsured and their costs are above a certain threshold, we will pay for the costs above that threshold. The issue is that when you have smaller hospitals they will not have discharges that meet that threshold but the costs are nonetheless catastrophic to them. In terms of how you can fund these options, most other states have chosen to fund their programs through traffic and civil and criminal fees, or taxes on licensure. There are constitutional against doing that in Wyoming . We also looked at county level funding districts or hospital districts. Most counties are already levying funds to support health care and it would require a vote to pass a greater taxation level. It would be difficult across the board to obtain the same participation in all counties to increase their taxes. There's the option of using state general revenue funds by coordinating with Medicaid to create supplemental payments based on the trauma care level of that hospital. The state could fund Medicaid to expand Medicaid coverage to provide some of these inpatient services provided to those who are current uninsured. Other states' are working to alleviate similar problems reported in the Wyoming study.

Commissioner Bryce asked for clarification of the ratio of 53 percent of costs to charges. Is that a constant markup through all procedures? That ratio you are speaking to is total estimated costs for the state fiscal year divided by total charges, Ms. Davidson said. If you looked at different services it would vary. Do we know where trauma charges fall on that spectrum of relativity? Yes, we broke down the estimated costs and charges in the Wyoming discharge database by payer. It would be helpful to add, but isn't possible to get, is the payment to charge or payment to cost ratio.

Chairman Muirhead said the subcommittee realizes the study provides good, albeit inconclusive, data. Clearly there is $10 million in uncompensated care. Maybe it's that $10 million we need to help the state realize is a large amount to small hospitals. Wyoming Hospital Association Vice President Dan Perdue said that this study is the result of efforts of his association and Wyoming Medical Center to put some money toward the unreimbursed care problem. The 2004 Legislature agreed to fund a WHCC study rather than allocate payments to hospitals. Getting quality data has been the problem. The data that has been shown to you is not complete but probably is as complete as it's going to get. Chairman Muirhead said this is an interesting study that has had tremendous downs because we've not been able to generate sufficient data to get the information we wanted but it's as good as it's going to get. Only seven hospitals had positive operating margins last year, he noted. When we talk about creating a recommendation potentially to the Legislature to help put $10 million back in these hospitals, a lot is going to go to small hospitals.

The study is a month behind schedule and now theoretically we have a Nov. 1 due date. I think the study stands by itself, Chairman Muirhead said. I don't think we as a commission are ready to make recommendations on the report's findings. My recommendation is, let's issue the study -- but we'll make a comment on it that we're not ready to make recommendations on this. This deserves more attention. We get to study the study before we get to say what should come forth, Commissioner Mossbrook said. I think the subcommittee will continue to work on this and try to generate recommendations prior to the 2005 legislative session, Chairman Muirhead said. If we feel that there's something else that needs to be studied, it is possible there is some money we could allocate to that. But we may take it away from other studies if we do that. I think the study is ready to hit the paper.

Commissioner Speight made a motion that we issue the study and open it up to a 30-day comment period before making recommendations to the Legislature. Motion seconded by Commissioner Lang. After discussion, Ms. Davidson agreed the consultants will revamp the executive summary to reflect the study's findings more succinctly. Could be done through a cover letter. Commissioner Muirhead noted it is ironic that the Wyoming State Planning Grant Task Force originated the study with a figure of $10 million in hospital payments attached to it – the portion of the recommendation not funded by the Legislature, as noted by WHA's Dan Perdue. But, he said, he can't report that we really have zeroed in on what's the best way to allocate it out. There's a lot of data in here to be looked at. In November, the subcommittee is going to be working on this but this is a difficult thing to get your hands around. We were supposed to identify the issue and we've done that. Our next recommendation will be, here is our suggestion on how you fund this. Navigant has enumerated some alternatives for us. I think the subcommittee would welcome any suggestions on how we ought to approach that. Public input will be made to the WHCC office. Rep. Jerry Iekel said that with Chairman Muirhead's permission, he will work with the subcommittee to draft legislation before the December Labor, Health and Social Services Subcommittee meeting. Motion passes unanimously.

Reports from Subcommittee Chairs Continued

Dixie Roberts – Medical Errors and Patient Safety (HANDOUT)
As we have gone through the medical errors and patient safety subcommittee study assignment, we've been overwhelmed with data. We called Harvard to get some assistance with project management. Dr. Michelle Mello said this was a well-written bill and it would take 10 years to complete the study, not the one year we were allocated. We do have some written material and paragraph summaries of the data out there. Dr. Mello provided some reading material and quick summaries. We have studies done in no fault states and international studies. The next step we're working on is, we've contracted with an MOU with Dr. Mello to help us blueprint our study, to bullet point studies out there and experts in the areas, and she'll have that in 30 days. We're compiling available data and looking at subsections we want to study. Commissioner Glode and Medical Errors and Patient Safety Study Project Coordinator Fran Cadez are going to Virginia in November to go to a JCAHO symposium where there will be many speakers doing presentations on medical errors. Participation in the conference can give us some “ins” to some of the experts and be able to talk to them.

T. Chris Muirhead – Medical Liability and Uncompensated Healthcare
A lot of the information we've talked about involves our subcommittee's work. The House Bill 1010 Section 4 study on caps has been released on time. As WHCC Chairman, I spent much of Oct. 18 on the telephone with news reporters discussing the caps study. I think it was well covered. It's out there and we did what the Legislature asked us to do. At this point in time, this study is complete. If voters do approve Constitutional Amendment D allowing for caps then we'll make recommendations, but we're on hold at this point. We talked about HB 1010 Section 2 this morning. We have just talked about the unreimbursed catastrophic and trauma care study. James Worthen, the UW Law student we've retained to do the analysis of the healthcare professional licensing boards' regulations, is due to report out by Nov. 30. Commissioners Speight and Vines and I are talking about and studying a closed claim reporting statute similar to what Nevada has instituted to address some of the issues with regard to lack of data policy makers have in this state on outcomes of litigation and malpractice. We have one more actuarial study, the risk retention group, due to us by Friday of this week. A telephonic conference has to be held and that report issued prior to the date of our next meeting. We will meet again with Richard Lord of Milliman, Inc., to do the same type of analysis we've done now with the Section 4 and Section 2 studies.

Audience Comments
None

Meeting Adjourned

Note: To obtain copies of handouts cited above, go to the site search box and type in the name of the person who's handout you would like. Hard copies can also be obtained by mail by calling 307-235-3227 emailing whcc@state.wy.us.

Top of page